Explore a topic

Government Transparency

Environmental test results can only guide decisions when they reach the people responsible for acting on them. Records about testing at the Town’s compost site show that results indicating soil contamination took a different route from later results showing no exceedances.

Ten soil samples were collected on December 12, 2024. The laboratory’s report, dated December 30, found that five samples exceeded applicable standards for one or more contaminants, including lead, petroleum hydrocarbons and PAHs. The report was addressed to the Town’s solicitor.

The Town had told MECP in November that it would provide the soil results once they were received. MECP records indicate it did not receive the report until June 13, 2025. In a June 4 email, the Director of Public Works said he did not have the report because it was being handled as solicitor-client privileged. The Town also withheld the report in response to a freedom-of-information request, citing privilege.

A later report covered four creek-water samples collected in March 2025. It was addressed to the Director of Public Works, reported no exceedances against the standards it applied, and was released publicly. These were different tests of different materials, taken at different locations. The creek-water results do not negate the soil findings or answer what may be present in the untested eastern wetlands.

When the Health Unit asked about sampling near the site in August, the CAO’s documented reply referred to the spring surface-water samples and said the results would be sent. The soil report was not mentioned in that exchange.

The records document a process in which the soil report was sent to the solicitor, was not available to the Director of Public Works, reached MECP more than five months after it was issued, and was withheld from the public. The available records do not establish how often this has happened or who decided to route the report this way. They do raise important questions about how environmental test results are reported, who receives them, and whether factual findings can be kept outside the Town’s normal operational records by sending them to legal counsel.

A campaign commitment to transparency

Smiths Falls now has a new Council, a new Mayor and a new Town Solicitor. This is an opportunity to review how the Town handles environmental testing records and claims of confidentiality or solicitor-client privilege.

Mayor Christopher Cummings made a campaign commitment to review those practices. Let’s work together to ensure he and Council follow through.

On September 26, then-candidate Christopher Cummings said he would support reviewing the Town’s policies on confidentiality and solicitor-client privilege:

“That said, I strongly believe that confidentiality should never become a convenient substitute for transparency.

“If elected Mayor, I would support reviewing the municipality’s practices and procedures around confidentiality and solicitor-client privilege to ensure they are being applied appropriately, consistently and only where there is a legitimate legal or public-interest reason for doing so. Where information can reasonably and legally be made public, I believe it should be.

“I would also support providing residents with clearer explanations, wherever possible, when information cannot be released. Sometimes the municipality may be legally justified in withholding information, but simply saying that something is confidential without helping residents understand why can understandably create frustration and mistrust.

“What I can commit to is the same principle I followed during my previous service on Council and that I have carried throughout this campaign: residents deserve an open and transparent municipal government, balanced with Council’s responsibility to protect legitimate legal, privacy and taxpayer interests.”

— Christopher Cummings, September 26, 2026, during the mayoral campaign

Residents can ask the Mayor and Council to take these steps:

  1. Contact the laboratories and consultants directly. Ask whether they have ever sent environmental or water-quality test results directly to the Town’s previous solicitor instead of to municipal staff. If so, ask them to resend those reports to the appropriate municipal staff and all members of Council.
  2. Determine who arranged or authorized this reporting route. Review the Town’s records to identify who directed the December soil report to the solicitor, when that decision was made, and whether similar instructions were given for other laboratory or consultant reports. Report the findings publicly.
  3. Remove the solicitor-client privilege designation from water-quality testing documents and release them to the public immediately. Where the Town believes a specific document must remain confidential, explain the legal basis clearly and identify what information can still be released.