Report # 2026-159
To: Mayor and Council
For Direction
From: Malcolm Morris, Chief Administrative Officer
Date: November 19, 2026
For Information
Committee of the Whole Date: November 23, 2026
For Adoption
Attachment 8 pages
Title: Court Security Costs
Recommendation: THAT Council of the Corporation of the Town of Smiths Falls authorize the Mayor and Clerk to execute a Memorandum of Understanding with the County of Lanark to formalize a cost sharing arrangement to distribute court security and transportation costs to <u><strong>lower tier municipalities and Smiths Falls based on weighted assessment.</strong></u>
Purpose: To formalize a cost sharing arrangement with the County of Lanark to equitably distribute net court security and transportation costs incurred by and for the Ontario Superior Court (Perth) among Smiths Falls and lower tier municipalities in Lanark County.
Background: The Perth Courthouse is the local Ontario Superior Court of Justice for civil, criminal, small claims, and family court; it serves Smiths Falls and all of Lanark County. The Community Safety and Policing Act (CSPA), 2019 states local police services boards are responsible for the provision of court security and prisoner transportation services. The salient excerpt from the act follows:
Court security
Police service boards
243 (1) A police service board that has policing responsibility for an area has the following responsibilities with respect to premises where court proceedings are conducted:
-
Ensuring the security of judges and other judicial officers and of persons taking part in or attending proceedings.
-
During the hours when judges, other judicial officers and members of the public are normally present, ensuring the security of the premises.
-
Ensuring the secure custody of persons in custody who are on or about the premises, including persons taken into custody at proceedings.
-
Determining appropriate levels of security for the purposes of paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 in accordance with the regulations, if any.
In the case of the Perth Courthouse, the OPP pass this cost on to the communities they police. The Town of Perth has historically administered security and transportation costs owing to the
Page 1 of 2 courthouse and receives a grant from the Province to cover the costs. The grant has not increased in a commensurate manner to the recent escalation in court security costs. The net cost has become a financial burden to the Town of Perth. An attempt was made by the Town of Perth to lobby the Office of the Solicitor General of Ontario for increased court security funding; their efforts did not produce a desirable result.
Analysis and Options: The County of Lanark has assumed responsibility for administering and accounting for the court security program, thus relieving Perth from incurring the net costs. While this arrangement provides a mechanism to collect from the lower tier municipalities, it does not solve the larger issue of questionable jurisdictional responsibility. Courts are, of course, a provincial responsibility. Notwithstanding, covering the cost of court security has not historically been an issue as grants from the province typically made municipalities whole. The disparity between actual security costs, being driven up by requests from court staff for heightened security, and generally static grant funding has widened. The resultant subsidization of provincial court operations represents a suitable subject for a coordinated advocacy effort by municipalities.
Deputy Police Chief Kettyle has confirmed that accused individuals from Smiths Falls are oftentimes transported to the courthouse in Perth via the OPP transportation service and are otherwise transported using SFPS resources.
Budget/Financial Implications: The proposed Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) distributes net court security and transportation costs based on weighted assessment of the lower tier municipalities and Smiths Falls. This methodology is quite common for shared services; costs for paramedic services, long term care, and social housing employ the same approach. The MOU would become effective on January 1, 2027. Based on historical costs over the past 7 years, the estimated net cost for court security and transportation in 2027 is $250k. Assessment figures fluctuate annually, but the most recent share for Smiths Falls is 9.24%. Accordingly, the estimated cost to the Town of Smiths Falls in 2027 is $23,100.
Link to Strategic Plan: Not applicable
Existing Policy: Not applicable
Consultations: Paul Dowber, Director of Corporate Servies/Treasurer; Chris Kettyle, Deputy Police Chief.
Attachments: Appendix A – County of Lanark Report # CAO-02-2026, dated April 8, 2026. Appendix B – Draft Memorandum of Understanding between the County of Lanark and Smiths Falls.
Notes/Action (space for Council Member’s notes):
Respectfully Submitted:
Malcolm Morris, CMO
Page 2 of 2
THE COUNTY OF LANARK
CORPORATE SERVICES COMMITTEE April 8, 2026
Report CAO-02-2026 of the CAO
Court Security & Prisoner Transport Costs
1. STAFF RECOMMENDATION
THAT, County Council direct staff to sign an agreement with the Town of Perth to assume administration and funding of Court Security and Transportation Costs starting in 2027;
AND THAT, Lanark County enter into an agreement for Smiths Falls to fund a proportion of the cost based on weighted assessment.
2. PURPOSE
To recognize court security and prisoner transfer as a cost to be shared by all municipalities in Lanark County.
3. BACKGROUND
The Perth Courthouse is the local Ontario Superior Court of Justice for Civil, Criminal, Criminal Youth, Small Claims and Family Court. It serves all of Lanark County and the Town of Smiths Falls.
The Smiths Falls Court closed as a regular trial court between 2022-2024.
4. DISCUSSION
The OPP provides court security which is paid for by the Town of Perth and the Town receives a provincial grant to partially cover the costs. The province has not increased the grant to keep up with the cost of security and the requirements for court security continue to increase. This had made court security a material expense to the Town.
In the last two years the County of Bruce, Grey County, Huron County and Northumberland County have all made agreements with the courthouse host municipality to provide funding.
Many municipalities, including the Town of Perth, have made delegations to the Solicitor
General to ask for increased funding. The Ministry’s response (at ROMA 2026) to Perth was to approach Lanark County to fund the service.
Court Security falls under the Community Safety and Policing Act, 2019. It is a statutory responsibility of the OPP commissioner/local detachment commander to provide court security and prisoner transfer.
| Year | Court Security and Prisoner Transportation Cost | Total Grant (Proportionate to Court Security/Transp.costs) | Net Cost to Perth |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $ 277,696 | $ 37,314 | $ 240,382 |
| 2025 | $ 269,084 | $ 26,384 | $ 242,700 |
5. ANALYSIS AND OPTIONS
Option #1: Status Quo
Option #1: Status Quo
Under this option the Town of Perth would continue to fund the costs above the provincial grant without any funding from other municipalities. Perth could make agreements with local municipalities to cost/share.
Option #2 Funding Grant
This option would see the County provide an annual grant to the Town of Perth for the previous years’ court security cost funding shortfall based on weighted assessment. The County’s grant would cover the seven other municipalities and not cover Perth’s or Smiths Falls’ portion. This would leave the Town of Perth to negotiate an agreement with Smiths Falls.
Option #3 Fund and Administer the Court Security Program (recommended option)
With this option Lanark County would take over all aspects of administration and accounting for the Court Security Program. This would require the County to negotiate an agreement with the (separated) Town of Smiths Falls.
6. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
The addition of Court Security would require an addition to the County levy. The amount is expected to growth as court security levels continue to increase.
7. LOCAL MUNICIPAL IMPACT
This recommendation would represent a cost shift from 100% the Town of Perth to cost sharing by weighted assessment across nine municipalities.
8. CLIMATE AND SUSTAINABILITY IMPACT
N/A
9. CONCLUSIONS
The recommendation is to recognize court security and prison transfer as a service provided for all municipalities in Lanark County and Smiths Falls and therefore proportionately share the cost.
10.ATTACHMENTS
None.
Recommended and
Approved for Submission
By:
Kurt Greaves, CAO
THE CORPORATION OF THE COUNTY OF LANARK
MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING (MOU)
Between:
CORPORATION OF THE COUNTY OF LANARK
herein referred to as the “COUNTY”,
OF THE FIRST PART
- and -
THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF SMITHS FALLS
herein referred to as the “TOWN”
OF THE SECOND PART
WHEREAS under the provisions of the COMMUNITY SAFETY IN POLICING ACT (CSPA) and associated Regulations, the Lanark County Detachment of the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) are responsible for the provision of court security and prisoner transportation (the “services”) at the Perth Courthouse;
AND WHEREAS, CSPA Regulation 413/23 removes court security and prisoner transportation costs from ‘base policing costs’ to be billed directly to municipalities that utilize OPP services;
AND WHEREAS, the Perth Courthouse is the principal center for criminal, civil, family and divisional court matters for residents of Lanark County and Smiths Falls and provides valuable service for the County and the Town;
AND WHEREAS the parties recognize that the programs and operations mentioned above are only partially funded by provincial grant programs;
AND WHEREAS the County of Lanark has agreed to incorporate Court Security and Prisoner Transportation costs incurred by the OPP Detachment into the annual budget to fairly distribute the costs of the service to all Lanark County municipalities through the County levy, on a weighted assessment basis;
AND WHEREAS the parties recognize that court cases emanating from the Town are typically held within the Perth Courthouse;
AND WHEREAS, the parties recognize that the Town will be responsible for their share of the costs of the services under a weighted assessment system, commensurate with other Lanark County municipalities;
NOW WITNESS THAT the parties hereto understand and outline the relationship to be as follows:
GENERAL
- The parties agree to the following general provisions, subject to any requirements within the “Community Safety and Policing Act” or similar legislation that may be announced by the Province of Ontario from time to time:
a. The County will incorporate costs for the services under this MOU into their annual budget, to be apportioned by weighted assessment. The weighted assessment will include the Town of Smiths Falls.
b. A monthly bill will be submitted by the County to the Town for their portion of the costs of the service under this agreement.
c. The Town will be responsible for the payment of their portion of the court security and prisoner transportation costs upon receipt of the billing amount.
ANNUAL BUDGET PLANNING
- The County commits to communicating with the Town of Smiths Falls, as soon as practicable, the expected cost of the services on an annual basis to be incorporated into the Town’s budget.
GRANT MANAGEMENT
-
The County commits to continuing to follow any appropriate processes to maintain or enhance provincial grant funding for the provision of the services;
-
The County agrees to maintain compliance with the requirements of the province as expressed through any applicable Transfer Payment Agreement (TPA) or any other requirements that may be added or imposed by the province from time to time. This includes but is not limited to:
a. Appropriate allocation of funds
b. Any required reporting
- The County agrees to maintain best practices in transparency and accountability in managing grant funding and furnish any documentation regarding the same to the Town upon request.
AUDITS
- The parties mutually agree to provide any relevant information to the other party as required to support and facilitate internal and external auditing processes.
INDEMNIFICATION - MUTUAL
- The parties shall mutually indemnify and hold harmless each other, their respective elected officials, officers, directors, employees and agents, from and against all claims, demands, losses, costs, damages, actions, suits or other proceedings (including reasonable legal fees) that the parties may suffer, incur or be liable for resulting from a negligent act, strict liability, breach of contract, error or omission, of each other’s elected officials, officers, directors, employees or agents in the performance of their obligations under this Agreement. The provisions of this paragraph shall survive the termination or expiry of this Agreement.
ASSIGNMENT
- This Agreement shall not be assignable by any party without the written consent of the other parties.
DISPUTES
-
The parties will try to resolve any difference between them on any matter in this Agreement by negotiation between themselves personally or by their lawyers.
-
In the event the Parties are unable to resolve their differences though negotiation as provided above, any dispute occurring between any of the Parties relating to the interpretation or implementation of any of the provisions of this Agreement shall be resolved in accordance with the following provisions:
a. The parties to the dispute shall first attempt in good faith to resolve such dispute by mediation.
b. If any issue in dispute is not resolved by mediation, it shall be submitted to arbitration. In that event, the following rules shall apply:
i. The arbitration shall be conducted by a single arbitrator appointed either by agreement between or among the disputing parties or, in default of such agreement, by a Judge of the Superior Court of Justice.
ii. Unless otherwise agreed by the disputing parties, the arbitration shall be conducted in the Town of Perth.
iii. The procedure to be followed shall be agreed upon by the disputing parties or, in default of such agreement, shall be determined by the arbitrator.
iv. The arbitration shall proceed in accordance with the provisions of the Arbitration Act, 1991 (Ontario).
v. The decision arrived at by the arbitrator shall be final and binding and no appeal shall lie therefrom. Judgment upon the award rendered by the arbitrator may be entered in any court having jurisdiction.
TERM
11.The term of this MOU shall be until termination notice is given by one or more parties.
12.This MOU may be terminated by either party by giving one hundred eighty (180) days’ notice in writing to the other parties.
CONTACT AND NOTICE
13.The contact for this MOU for the County of Lanark shall be the Clerk, as appointed by Council from time to time. The contact for the Town shall be the Clerk, as appointed by Council from time to time.
14.Notice under this agreement shall be provided in writing by mail or other electronic means to the contact.
MISC
15.The invalidity or unenforceability of any provision of this Agreement will not affect the validity or enforceability of any other provision and any invalid provision will be severable.
16.Unless otherwise provided, this Agreement shall not be amended or modified in any respect otherwise than in writing and executed by the parties hereto.
17.This Agreement may be executed electronically or otherwise, in one or more counterparts, each of which shall constitute an original and all of which take together shall constitute the same agreement.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF the parties have executed this document this ____ day of ________, 2026
ON BEHALF OF THE CORPORATION OF THE COUNTY OF LANARK
Jasmin Ralph, Clerk
ON BEHALF OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF SMITHS FALLS
Richard Kidd, Warden
Kerry Costello, Clerk
Shawn Pankow, Mayor

