PARKS AND SAFETY
Front Cover Images Sourced From: smithsfalls.ca
TPXO of SNJUIT FBMMT
Town of Smiths Falls
Play.
Connect.
Explore.
PARKS AND RECREATION MASTER PLAN
JUNE 2022
The image shows a serene river flowing through a lush green landscape. A bridge spans the river, with a flat roof and railings on both sides. The trees surrounding the river are vibrant yellow and green, creating a picturesque scene under a bright blue sky with fluffy white clouds.
PARKS
PARKS
D
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Great communities are built through active citizen involvement and engagement in the planning process. Many thanks go out to Town Council and administration who assisted in this effort, and recognized the importance of investing in long term planning.
Of most importance, thanks go out to the:
• Residents of Smiths Falls for participating in the household and youth surveys;
• Representatives of community groups and stakeholder organizations who answered questionnaires and attended meetings to discuss their needs;
• All other key stakeholders who provided information and attended meetings when asked.
Special thanks go to the project steering committee who assisted in this planning effort (through the provision of advice, information, support, and opinions); who recognized the importance of investing in long range planning; and who displayed the fortitude to make decisions in the best interest of the community. The project steering committee:
• Art Manhire, Director, Community Services, Town of Smiths Falls
• Tana Torch, Administrative Coordinator, Community Services, Town of Smiths Falls
• Karl Grenke, Senior Planner, Town of Smiths Falls
• RC Strategies
PROJECT DOCUMENTS
Three documents form the Town of Smiths Falls Parks and Recreation Master Plan
Smiths Falls Parks and Recreation Master Plan
STATE OF PARKS AND RECREATION IN THE TOWN OF SMITH'S FALLS
DECEMBER 2021
SMITH'S FALLS ONE AT THE FALLS
FCS+
State of Parks and Recreation
Research and Engagement
Summary Report
Summary Report AND RECREATION
A PLAYGROUND REPLACEMENT STRATEGY FOR SMITHS FALLS DECEMBER 2021 SMITHS FALLS HAVE IN THE FALLS rcs+
Playground Replacement Strategy
Years of Smiths Falls PARKS AND RECREATION MASTER PLAN DECEMBER 2017 SMITHS PALLS NEW AT THE HOLIDAYS FCC
Parks and Recreation Master Plan
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Town of Smiths Falls initiated its first Parks and Recreation Master Plan in 2021 with the expectation for the planning process to engage residents and stakeholders in thinking about priorities for parks and recreation over the next 10 years.
The Master Plan
• Sets a foundation and establishes a structure that will inform capital project planning and service delivery options.
• Provides Council and staff with insights and rationale that can inform business and strategic planning, as well as asset management.
• Offers tools and processes that can guide Council and staff decision making related to future parkland acquisition and development.
• Provides a point of reference that rationalizes ongoing investment into parks and recreation by articulating the public benefits of quality parks and recreation facilities and services.
7
Three reports were created during the development of the Master Plan:
State of Parks and Recreation Research and Engagement
Summary Report: A comprehensive review and analysis of the existing situation in Smiths Falls along, with applicable research, with implications for the development of the Master Plan. This document summarizes what we heard from the public and stakeholders that participated in consultation activities undertaken for the project.
Playground Replacement Strategy: A document offering a site-by-site consideration of existing playground equipment in Smiths Falls and a strategy for renewal and replacement, which considers external trends in playground design and development. Ongoing playground and maintenance practices are also provided in this report.
The Parks and Recreation Master Plan: This document is the Master Plan. It is framed around 4 Service Delivery Principles and a corresponding set of focused strategic priorities and actions to guide planning and support decision making over the next 10 years.
PLAYGROUND
Resident and Stakeholder Input was critical in the development of this Master Plan
Resident Survey
(Coded Version)
221 Responses
Resident Survey
(Open / Non-Coded Version)
122 Responses
Youth Questionnaire
145 Responses
Stakeholder and Community Group Engagement
13 virtual discussion sessions with representatives from 22 organizations / interests in the community
3 responses to an online Community Organization Questionnaire
Service Delivery Principles Key Action Items:
The following Service Delivery Principles represent an overarching agenda of this Master Plan and a structure for it. They are: Growing Participation and Building Capacity, Acquiring and Renewing Parkland, Renewing Outdoor Facilities and Renewing and Diversifying Indoor Facilities. Identified in this section are some key action items for each principle.
Service Delivery Principle: Growing Participation and Building Capacity
Service Delivery Principle: Growing
Key action items:
• Attract / invite third party service providers to offer introductory, learn-to-play recreation programs in Smiths Falls. The Town should directly provide programs of this nature if other providers are not available to do so.
• Pursue program partnerships with health-focused and funded organizations to deliver health promotion and physical activity programs for older persons.
• Work with sport organizations to recruit and train volunteer coaches to offer house level hockey and competitive level field sports.
• Develop a sport field allocation policy.
• Develop a Community Organization Support Program.
• Migrate facility rental contracts and allocation permits to the registration and facility management platform.
• Collect and report use statistics for all major recreation facilities and maintain records on utilization trends for future planning purposes.
Service Delivery Principle: Acquiring and Developing Parkland
Service Delivery Principle: Acquiring and
Key action items:
• Optimize parkland acquisition strategies to ensure future residential areas enjoy equitable access to parkland.
• Complete the Vision for Waterfront Parks in collaboration with Parks Canada.
• Implement the Active Transportation Master Plan.
Service Delivery Principle: Renewing Outdoor Facilities
Service Delivery Principle: Renewing Outdoor
Key action items:
• Immediately initiate a design process for the replacement of existing play structures at Hyland & Corbett Park and Victoria Park.
• Establish a playground replacement program as an annual capital budget line item to address ongoing asset management needs, including accessibility upgrades (equipment, pathways, seating, etc.).
• Resurface the paved sport court at Lower Reach Park. Provide court lighting and connect to the parking area by a defined internal multi-recreational trail or park path.
• Continue to monitor pickleball activity trends and regional provision.
• Ensure that playgrounds are provided in new residential development areas based on an 800 metre service area. Playground equipment should be installed during the initial phases of Bellamy Farms development.
• Assess removing the ball diamond at Hyland & Corbett Park as part of a broader playground renewal and park revisioning process recommended in the Playground Action Plan section.
Service Delivery Principle: Renewing and Diversifying Indoor Facilities
Key action items:
Service Delivery Principle: Renewing and
•
Continue to optimize community use of Board of Education gymnasiums and, where possible, determine solutions and approaches to issues that limit community gymnasium time.
•
Undertake an Indoor Multi Sport Facility Feasibility Study with interested surrounding municipalities and the Upper Canada District School Board to assess demand, viability, and model of operation of an indoor multisport facility on municipal or Board of Education lands.
•
Continue to monitor prime time and shoulder season utilization closely and enhance statistics collected from permit holders to track trends in player participation and residency. Provide a utilization report to Council annually.
•
Work with ice arena user groups to determine strategies to increase participation and ice arena utilization within the parameters of their governing sport bodies Long Term Player Development plans.
•
Ice sport user groups are encouraged to offer recreational, learn-to-play programs that introduce children and youth to fundamental skills.
•
While demand for prime time utilization of ice at the Youth Arena is expected to remain strong, if annual utilization falls below 60% of total available hours for two consecutive years, an Arena Ice Review should be undertaken to assess future ice requirements.
Advancing Highest Priority Projects that Require Capital Funding
The highest facility priority for capital funding is the replacement and renewal of playground equipment. To ensure the completion of the Playground Replacement Strategy and ensure that there are the appropriate available funds for ongoing maintenance and repairs, sustained multi-year funding is required. The table below provides a plan to schedule a work and funding program over the next 5 years.
| Action | Scope | Estimated Funding Required Funding (2022 dollars) | Timing | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Replace Playground at Victoria Park | See Playground Replacement Strategy for guidance | $125,000 (site works, installation, play equipment) | 2022 | Removal of the existing wading pool should be completed at this location in conjunction with construction at this site. |
| Replace Playground at Hyland Park | See Playground Replacement Strategy for guidance | $125,000 (site works, installation, play equipment) | 2022 | |
| Neighbourhood consultation, site design and equipment selection for all playground sites | Detailed design packages with technical specifications are prepared for each site | $40-50,000 | 2023 | This planning effort can be phased over multiple years based on available funding. |
| Enhance and Renew Playground at Lower Reach Park | See Playground Replacement Strategy for guidance | $250,000-$300,000 (site works, installation, play equipment) | 2025 | This location is identified as a community-wide Accessible Playground |
| Add a Playground at the Memorial Arena Community Centre | See Playground Replacement Strategy for guidance | $250,000 (site works, installation, play equipment) | 2026-27 | This is a new site. A location will be required. |
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1 1 2 4 4 6 7 8 9 9 11 14 15 15 17 19
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A FRAMEWORK FOR PRIORITIZING FUTURE NEEDS 23 THE PRIORITIZATION FRAMEWORK 23 27 27 34 34 41 42 43 44 APPENDICES 45 45 49
INTRODUCTION
What is the Master Plan?
The Town of Smiths Falls initiated its first Parks and Recreation Master Plan in 2021 with expectation for the planning process to engage residents and stakeholders in thinking about priorities for parks and recreation over the next 10 years.
More specifically, the Master Plan will:
• Set foundations and establish structure that will inform capital project planning and service delivery options.
• Provide Council and staff with insights and rationale that can inform business and strategic planning and asset management.
• Offer tools and processes that can guide Council and staff decision making related to future parkland acquisition and development.
• Provide a point of reference that rationalizes ongoing investment into parks and recreation by articulating the public benefits of quality parks and recreation facilities and services.
Source: smithsfalls.ca
How was the Master Plan Developed?
The Town of Smiths Falls retained RC Strategies to develop the Master Plan. The following graphic illustrates the major work elements involved in creating this Master Plan document.
Research
• Trends and Leading Practices
• Review of the Town’s Strategies, Master Plans and Relevant Policies
• Review and analysis of current service delivery practices
• Community Analysis (review of population and demographic indicators)
• Utilization Analysis of the Town’s Facilities
• Benchmarking (comparisons to other communities)
• Functional Assessment of Key Indoor and Outdoor Facilities and Parks
Master Plan Directions
• Identifying Themes
• Establishing and Sequencing Priorities
Engagement
• Interviews with Facility Users and Community Organizations (13 sessions)
• Coded Resident Survey (221 responses)
• Open Resident Survey (122 responses)
• Youth Questionnaire (145 responses)
Master Plan Development
•
Writing the Master Plan
• Securing Approvals
Do you kn
The 202 km length of the Canal was designated World Heritage Site as Outstanding Universa
Do you know?
The 202 km length of the Rideau Canal was designated as a UNESCO World Heritage Site as an Outstanding Universal Value and is the oldest continuously operated canal in North America. Smiths Falls' location is central to this canal, and three of the canals lockstations are in the area.
2
KEY FINDINGS FROM THE RESEARCH AND ENGAGEMENT
Insights from research activities and engagement with the community and stakeholders have informed the development of the Master Plan Foundations, Strategies and Priorities (as presented in the next three sections). This section offers a summary of key findings from the State of Recreation and Parks in Smiths Falls Research Report that is under separate cover.
Key Findings from the Research
Community Profile: Amongst the most significant expected demographic shifts is a doubling of the population aged 65 and older within the next 10 years. The population of children and youth is anticipated to remain relatively stable to 2030. The prevalence of low-income households is also higher than the County average. Demand for age friendly and low/no fee parks and recreation facilities and services should be anticipated. Population growth driven demand for minor sport and children and youth-oriented programs is not expected.
Diverse & Aging Facilities and Amenities:
Smiths Falls owns and operates a significant asset base of parks and recreation amenities.
Functional assessments undertaken on key recreation and parks facilities indicate that the Town generally does a good job maintaining assets, although opportunities exist to revision and refresh several spaces in coming years (especially with respect to community and local parks and play structures).
Front Cover Images Sourced From: smithsfalls.ca
Smiths Falls Parks and Recreation Master Plan
STATE OF PARKS AND RECREATION IN THE TOWN OF
MAY 2021
SMITHS FALLS
SMITHS FALLS RISE AT THE FALLS
rcs+
Available prime time ice utilization data for both ice surfaces suggests reasonably high utilization.
Trends research, however, suggests a declining
participation in minor ice sport due to factors such as costs to
play and time commitments required of players and parents.
Population-driven demand factors are not expected to bump
up utilization over the next ten years in Smiths Falls; there are
relatively few introductory level ice sport programs for children
and youth on offer. Significant ice equipment renewal is
anticipated for the Youth Arena in the near term.
Opportunities exist to improve sport field allocation practices, data collection and revenue generation and extend the season of use.
Transitioning to pay-per-period-of-use allocation system will allow the Town to modernize its permitting system (by moving it online) and enhance collection and analysis of utilization data (by collecting it in the online system). Sport field user fees are comparably low against fees charged by similar sized municipalities and the existing practice of teams remitting a perplayer fee for season use of sport field is impossible for staff to verify and may be resulting in revenue loss. Opportunity exists to improve the sport field allocation process and revenue generation. Transitioning to an online booking platform will improve data collection and analysis. Moving away from the per-player fee to a pay-per-period-of-use allocation system with sport fields would align with similar size municipalities that have achieved higher revenue off of field usage fees. A per-player fee system requires more staff time to verify and results in inconsistent revenue for similarly booked fields.
Supporting player development is an important factor in achieving stable facility and amenity utilization. There are relatively few local sport
organizations in Smiths Falls that offer house and competitive level programs for youth; competitive level players join teams and leagues in other communities. The progression from house level play to competitive level play ensures a stronger overall level of asset use, and in most cases, results in an extended playing season. Developing local strategies to build up competitive level youth sport programs would keep youth engaged in physical activity longer and help to optimize the use of the Town’s facilities and amenities.
There are indications of demand for indoor multi- purpose activity space. The Town does not
currently provide an indoor space suitable to
accommodate a variety of indoor sports during the winter
such as basketball, floor hockey, indoor soccer, or pickleball.
The Gallipeau Centre and the Board of Education offer
community access to gymnasiums but demand often
exceeds supply.
There is plenty of parkland, but it’s mostly concentrated adjacent to the river. Additional parkland should be acquired in new residential areas that are distant from existing waterfront parks to provide local play space and “complete” new neighbourhoods.
Play spaces and play structure equipment across the Town requires renewal. Each local park renewal project is an opportunity to engage the local neighbourhood in a dialogue about what features and amenities might best address local needs. Parks that offer multi-generational and physically accessible amenities will appeal to the largest cross-section of users.
Findings from Engagement with Community and Stakeholders
Recreation and Parks are strongly associated as a “public good” by residents. Residents strongly
indicated that parks and recreation are important to both their household and the community as a whole. In fact, residents attributed greater importance of parks and recreation opportunities to quality of life for all residents (74%) and to the appeal and attractiveness of Smiths Falls for prospective and current residents (81%) than parks and recreation are to themselves and members of their household.
“public good” by residents. Residents strongly
The main reasons that residents participate in parks and recreation activities are to be physically active (80%), pleasure (64%), to
be with family (64%) and to enjoy nature (59%). A significant proportion of recreational activity occurs in an unstructured manner (not part of an organized program, team or league). The findings also reiterate the diversity of recreation activity participation that occurs in the community.
Youth Survey respondents indicated that the cost of participating, lack of awareness of opportunities, being too busy to participate, poor / inadequate facilities, and overcrowded facilities were the top five barriers to participating in parks and recreation services.
Levels of satisfaction with most aspects of parks and recreation are relatively strong but have room for improvement - 82% of Coded Resident
Questionnaire respondents were satisfied (“very” or “somewhat”) with parks, trails and open spaces in Smiths Falls. Levels of satisfaction for sport programs and opportunities, and the availability of recreation programs and facilities were not as strong – about a quarter of respondents identified that they were “dissatisfied” with these service areas (respondents had higher levels of “neither satisfied nor dissatisfied” responses).
The top 5 indoor spaces that respondents indicated that they would like to see enhanced and/or more of were libraries, arts and crafts
creative spaces, indoor children’s play spaces, seniors spaces, and indoor multi-sport facilities. The top 5 outdoor spaces that respondents indicated that they would like to see enhanced and/or more of were natural surface trails, paved community trails, BBQ and picnic areas / park shelters, playgrounds and outdoor festival and community performance spaces.
Residents are mixed on whether they would support increased taxes to sustain and enhance parks and recreation services. The highest
proportion of survey respondents believe current user fees should be maintained while less than one-fifth support an increase.
parks and recreation services. The highest
User groups and stakeholders placed emphasis on improving systems and modernizing customer
service. Stakeholders identified that having an option to book facilities online would improve the booking process.
Indoor multi-purpose dry floor space, arts and crafts spaces, trails, and park amenities were identified as top, infrastructure priorities.
Demand for these types of parks and recreation infrastructure was relatively consistent throughout the engagement. The Master Plan will need to further assess the need for these spaces and the associated cost impacts.
THE STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK
The Town supports parks and recreation opportunities to enhance the quality of life for residents, employers, and visitors. Parks and recreation improve health outcomes for individuals and communities and connect us with natural environments so that we might find balance in our busy lives and learn to appreciate and protect nature in its many forms.
Four Service Delivery Principles reflect the ambition of the Master Plan and serve to focus attention on stated priorities and suggested actions. Priorities and actions are organized according to the Service Delivery Principles.
Provided in this section is an overview of the four Service Delivery Principles for parks and recreation in Smiths Falls.
How were the Parks and Recreation Service Delivery Principles developed?
The Service Delivery Principles reflect sentiment identified through engagement with residents, community organizations and stakeholders, and staff, and have also been developed to align with the Town’s Strategic Plan and Official Plan as well as national and provincial strategies, action plans and frameworks outlined in the State of Parks and Recreation in Smiths Falls Research Report.
Service Delivery Principles
The term “Service Delivery” refers to the approaches and methods that the Town of Smiths Falls uses to provide parks and recreation facilities and opportunities. The following Service Delivery Principles represent an overarching agenda of this Master Plan and a structure for it.
Growing Participation and Building Capacity
What does this mean?
The Town will support organizations that provide sport, recreation, and leisure programs with a goal of increasing participation in affordable, fun, and healthy activities.
Why is this important?
Sport, recreation, and leisure
programs in Smiths Falls are
mostly provided to the public
by not-for-profit or
for-profit organizations that
rent the Town’s indoor and
outdoor facilities to deliver.
Building the capacity of
these organizations to
respond to community needs
and interests will generate
greater participation and
utilization of recreation
facilities provided by the
Town. Optimization of
municipal policies and
practices that impact these
organizations also relates to
this principle.
Acquiring and Renewing Parkland
What does this mean?
The Town will prioritize strategic investments to acquire new and renew existing parkland.
Why is this important?
Q uality parks and outdoor
recreation spaces promote
healthy outdoor physical
activity and provide a place
for residents and visitors to
gather. Continuous
reinvestment in parks
ensures that outdoor areas
can accommodate a higher
frequency of daily users and
contribute to local
economic development.
Investment in new park
development is required in
new residential areas to
ensure all residents have
accesses to a quality park.
Renewing Outdoor Facilities
What does this mean?
The Town will provide, replace, and maintain outdoor recreation facilities that offer a quality, safe and accessible experience for users.
Why is this important?
A well-maintained, safe and accessible outdoor recreation facility, such as a sport field, ball diamond, playground or court, is expected by users. Investing in the renewal or replacing of facilities that have reached the end of their useful lifecycle will gradually offer a higher quality parks system that attracts a broader range of users.
Renewing and Diversifying Indoor Facilities
What does this mean?
The Town will explore opportunities to provide new indoor spaces for recreation and sporting activities while maintaining existing facilities in response to demand.
Why is this important?
The Town will strategically invest in facility renewal and explore possibilities for future facility provision that may offer different types of indoor recreation spaces that respond to community needs.
It’s important to continuously assess the utilization of existing indoor recreation facilities and to consider adjustments to the indoor facility inventory that are responsive to the needs and interests of a broader range of user interests and activity preferences.
4
GROWING PARTICIPATION AND BUILDING CAPACITY
This section highlights priorities and actions that elevate the focus on system-wide enhancements or targeted initiatives that will extend support to community organizations that play a big role in the delivery of sport and recreation in Smiths Falls. Each Priority is supported by rationale from the research and public consultation. More detailed actions are suggested to advance the priority through annual business and operational plans.
The Town’s Approach to Providing Parks and Recreation Services
Municipalities across Canada and in Ontario approach service delivery of parks and recreation from three common perspectives: As a direct provider, a service enabler, or as a contract manager. While many responsibilities are common to all perspectives and do shift based on local demands and expectations, the following figure identifies what each perspective holds unique. The Town of Smiths Falls current approach to delivery fits most closely with the service enabler perspective; 4.38 full time employees are currently allocated to supporting parks and recreation service delivery focused around three main areas: Lower Reach Park, Municipal Arena Complex, and the Town Hall Precinct.
Source: smithsfalls.ca
At a system-wide level, the Community Services Department allocates rental contracts to community organizations, supports not-for-profit organizations that provide services to the community, supports over 60 annual community events.
Direct Provider
• Customer is mainly the program participant.
• Offers programs and services directly to users and maintains critical resources, infrastructure, and systems to operate as a direct provider (i.e., program instructors, program equipment, registration, marketing systems.
• Offers programs and provides services for identified target populations often at no or very low cost to the user.
Service Enabler
•
Customer is mainly other businesses.
•
Provides and manages indoor and outdoor facilities that are rented by independent businesses or not-for-profit organizations who provide a program or service to users.
•
Municipal staff apply community development methods to support and strengthen organizations that use municipal facilities.
Contract Manager
•
A third party, like a YMCA or a commercial operator, provides recreation programs and services under contractual terms or with funding support from the local municipality (or both).
•
Facilities are often owned and operated by the third party, sometimes on land leased from the municipality.
•
Parks and outdoor recreation facilities are commonly provided by the municipality.
Supporting Community-Driven Recreation
Priority: Support community-driven organizations that provide programs, events, and initiatives that require the Town’s indoor and outdoor recreation facilities.
Rationale
The Town’s current “enabler” approach to recreation service delivery means that it does not directly deliver recreation programs and services to residents. The approach appears to be accommodating much of the demand that can be absorbed by commercial, for-profit, and not-for-profit service providers, even though resident satisfaction with the available offerings, awareness of programs and overall affordability, as measured in the coded survey and youth survey suggest there is room for enhancement.
There are gaps in the continuum of sport development that should be addressed to increase utilization of the Town’s major recreation facilities. Introductory/house league hockey programs for children are necessary to stimulate long-term demand for an arena. Similarly, competitive youth field sports are necessary in Smiths Falls to achieve stable demand for local sport field utilization. Participation in sport for life begins in childhood. Continued progression through sport underpins the long-term demand envisioned for planned recreation facilities.
The demographic characteristics of Smiths Falls also suggest that price sensitivity and affordability are significant determinants of participation in recreation programs. Demand for low cost or free seasonal children’s programs that are supported or delivered by the Town will have more significant social impact. Survey respondents demonstrated interest in supervised play and introduction to sport programs that are mostly delivered by a municipal provider that can absorb a lower cost-recovery rate. More importantly, municipalities can implement fee assistance programs that provide targeted support for more vulnerable households; most commercial providers cannot.
Actions
•
Attract / invite third party service providers to offer introductory, learn-to-play recreation programs in Smiths Falls. The Town should directly provide programs of this nature if other providers are not available to do so.
•
Pursue program partnerships with health-focused and funded organizations to deliver health promotion and physical activity programs for older adults and seniors.
•
Work with sport organizations to recruit and train volunteer coaches to offer house level hockey and competitive level field sports.
•
Develop a formal fee assistance policy and program that users of community-provided services can access to extend the benefits of recreation and sport to all children and youth in Smiths Falls.
•
Directly deliver no/low fee recreation programs for children and youth that offer targeted social and community impacts.
•
Develop a Sport Field Allocation Policy. The following interests should be considered when developing a Sport Field Allocation and Permitting Policy:
» Establish different hourly rates for different types of groups (youth, adult, commercial, etc.).
» Determine if and how non-resident players should be considered and if non-residents should pay a higher fee.
» How costs for additional services, such as field lighting, should be recovered.
» The optimal and minimum duration of the field maintenance and playing season.
• Develop a Community Organization Support Program that provides the following targeted supports:
» Grant identification and grant writing support.
» Training and learning opportunities for volunteer board members.
» Coordinated marketing support.
» Coordinated, online program registration support through links on the Town’s program registration software.
» Volunteer recruitment and recognition programs.
» Continue to host annual forums and information sessions with community organizations and service providers to enhance community awareness and discuss topics of interest.
» Continue to utilize and enhance a variety of communication tools to promote and gather feedback on services and initiatives.
Smiths Falls Youth Arena
71A
Source: smithsfalls.co
Source: smithfalls.ca
CANOE TRAINING
Supporting Planning and Decision Making by Enhancing Data Collection
<em>Priority:</em> Collect and routinely analyze more data to support service and <em>facility planning and decision making</em>
Rationale
The Town is implementing registration and facility
management software that offers functionality to automate
many paper-based, in-person transactions such as rental
contracts. Programs and memberships that the Town may
offer in the future can be managed through this platform.
Analyzing detailed transaction data offers many insights into
the overall performance of the Town’s parks and recreation
system.
Actions
• Complete implementation of the registration and facility management platform.
• Migrate facility rental contracts and allocation permits to the registration and facility management platform.
• Collect and report use statistics for all major recreation facilities and maintain records on utilization trends for future planning purposes.
• Determine current cost-recovery rates using activity-based accounting practices to inform rates and fees determination.
• Create a membership and issue membership cards for walking track users to scan during each visit to track use.
• Use the Town’s Asset Management software to record all facility maintenance and inspection records on all indoor and outdoor facility and parkland assets.
Source: smithsfalls.ca
ACQUIRING AND DEVELOPING PARKLAND
This section offers planning guidance and a package of strategies and actions for acquiring, developing and renewing the Town’s parkland assets within a broader planning context of public green spaces, protected natural areas, conservation areas, and Parks Canada lands.
Inventory of Parks and Parkland
The Town of Smiths Falls owns or manages approximately 33.27 hectares of designated parkland in the parks marked in the map aside. A further two new parks will be acquired by the Town through Plans of Subdivision approved by the Town (not currently showing on the map). While there is no mandated provincial or national standard to which parkland per capita should be measured against, many municipalities plan to acquire and manage a total supply of parkland between 2.5-3.5 hectares per 1,000 population. At 4.07 hectares of parkland per 1,000 population, Smiths Falls is well supplied from a total provision perspective.
FAMILY survey % of trails and ne r hiking, running. es were as a high by survey
Source: smithsfoils.ca
The Resident Survey found that 79% of residents use trails and pathways in the community for hiking, walking and running. These amenities were also identified as a high value priority by s respondents.
Community Local Waterfront Other Municipal Boundary Town Owned Land Open Space (54.6 ha)
Via Rail Alexander Park
Hillcrest Cemetery
Memorial Community Centre Outdoor Area
Curry Lowe/Sane Rink
Kinsmen Park
Hyland Park
Corbett
Conotaph Park
Civitan Memorial Park
Sherwood Park
Murphy Park
Turtle Island
Centennial Park
Post-War Housing Park
Duck Island
Victoria Park
Lower Reach Park
Civitan Park
Cleopon Park
Off-Leash Dog Park
Lee St Park
Code Crescent Park
Parkland Classification
Core to park planning is the parkland classification system. Distinguishing characteristics by type of parkland, such as size, function, and development of an amenity provides a consistent management approach and a frame for the public, developers and planners to design new parks. The Parks and Recreation Master Plan classifies parkland as either Waterfront, Community or Local Parkland. The following table describes the general characteristics and supply of each type of parkland. These classifications are consistent with the Town of Smiths Falls Official Plan (2016), with the exception that Community Parkland has been segregated further into Waterfront Parkland in the recognition of the unique joint-management functions between the Town and Parks Canada on several strategy park parcels and commitments to collaborate in the further development of these assets.
| Suggested Parkland Classification | ||
|---|---|---|
| Waterfront Parkland | Community Parkland | Local Parkland |
| • Accommodates town-wide recreation and leisure interests. | • Accommodates the recreation and leisure interests. | • Accommodates residential interests. |
| • Provides facilities for major events or those that attract residents/visitors from a wider geographic area. These parks might be considered “tourism assets” and may be developed to generate revenue to offset tax-base support. | • Provides facilities for organized sports (ball diamonds and athletic fields) that are adjacent to community centres or halls, or at stand-alone parks. | • Provides facilities such as park benches, small play structures, and undeveloped open space for passive or active recreation and leisure activities. |
| • Typical facilities may include those listed for Community Parkland. | • Provides facilities for play, including larger playgrounds, skateboard parks, basketball courts, etc. | • Local parks are typically developed depending on local interest and local volunteer effort. |
| • Preserves unique natural, cultural, or historical areas of significance. | • Provides passive open space for instructed leisure activities. | • May be left undeveloped as a natural area or woodlot. |
| • Are linked, by means of trails, waterways or paved walking paths to other parks, retail areas, and other services. | • Promotes a “local flavour” with respect to historical features, gardens, etc. |
• May provide beach access and a
| Suggested Parkland Classification | ||
|---|---|---|
| Waterfront Parkland | Community Parkland | Local Parkland |
| General Size: | General Size: | General Size: |
| Dependent on geographic features and location, shape of land, and development conditions. | Min. 4 hectares | 0.5 – 2.5 hectares |
| Current Supply: | Current Supply: | Current Supply: |
| 2.49 Ha. Per 1000 Capita | 0.83 Ha. Per 1000 Capita | 0.46 Ha. Per 1000 Capita |
| Assigned Parks: | Assigned Parks: | Assigned Parks: |
| Lower Reach Park | Gleeson Park | Sherwood Park |
| Victoria Park | Civitian Memorial Park | Hyland & Corbett Park |
| Duck Island | Cenotaph Park | Kinsmen Park |
| Turtle Island | Memorial Community Centre Outdoor Area | Post-War Housing Park |
| Murphy Park | Hillcrest Cemetery | Bellamy Farms 1 (unnamed) |
| Bellamy Farms 2 (unnamed) |
Source: smithsfalls.ca
Inventory of Trails and Routes
| Recreational Routes and Trails | Description |
|---|---|
| Catarqui Trail | 104 km. multi-use recreation trail from Smiths Falls to Strathcona |
| Rideau Trail | 387 km. trail that extends from Kingston to Ottawa and transits through Smiths Falls. |
| Smiths Falls ATV Trail | 130 km. ATV trail from Carleton Place to Plum Hollow |
| Smiths Falls Snowmobile Trail | 224 km. snowmobile trail from Smiths Falls to Kingston parallel the Rideau Canal |
| Ottawa Valley Recreational Trail (OVRT) | 296 km. multi-use recreation trail from Smiths Falls to Ottawa |
| Walking Routes | Description |
| Smiths Falls Walking Trail | 5 km. from Lower Reach Park to Centennial Park |
Source: Town of Smiths Falls Website (2021) and Town of Smiths Falls GIS
Do you know?
Do you know? Rideau Canal
hectares of designated parkland Smiths Falls to Ottawa
There is approximately 33.27 hectares of designated parkland in Smiths Falls.
<em>Priority:</em> Optimize parkland acquisition strategies to ensure future residential <em>areas enjoy equitable access to parkland.</em>
Rationale
The Town’s Official Plan recognizes the importance of acquiring and managing municipal parkland for quality-of-life benefits for residents and for contributing to broader natural systems that are increasingly protected and managed by different organizations and landowners.
The Town’s largest parks orient to the canal waterfront where significant investment in outdoor recreation facilities has been made to accommodate active and passive uses, including multi-use recreation trails.
While the guidance offered in this section may inform redevelopment of existing parkland, it is primarily intended to inform planning and decision making related to future acquisitions and parkland developments. Local, neighbourhood-oriented parks in long-established residential areas have attracted less reinvestment and now require renewal. Intensification is occurring in some existing residential areas and previously approved residential subdivisions are in the early phases of construction.
Lakeview
Parkland Strategy Statements
- Maintain the current parkland to population service level of 3.80-4.00 Ha. per 1,000 persons.
» Maintaining this service level suggests that the Town should acquire parkland for growth-related needs only. Given projected growth of an additional 1,000 population over the next ten years, an additional 4 Ha. of parkland may be required.
- Incorporate the revised Parkland Classification System in the Official Plan to focus acquisition and parkland development efforts.
» Used in association with other policies in the Official Plan, the Parkland Classification System offers a framework for acquiring the most appropriate type of parkland a major development should provide through the development process.
-
Ensure equitable access to municipal parks by ensuring that all residential properties have access to a municipal park with a play structure within 800 meters or 10 minutes walking distance. This is important for new residential areas.
-
In alignment with the Parkland Classification System, ensure that land conveyed for parkland is centrally located, pedestrian accessible and graded flat for future parkland development. These interests work in alignment with policies in section 7.1.9 of the Town’s Official Plan.
-
Recognize the Town’s multi-use recreational trails in municipal parks in the Town’s Official Plan and Active Transportation Strategy.
-
Review Natural Areas / Green Space policies in the Town’s Official Plan to identify optimal lands for acquisition in collaboration with other agencies and appropriate land management strategies for these areas.
Accept cash-in-lieu of parkland conveyance in accordance with the Planning Act and the Town’s Official Plan. Apply the following criteria for determining acceptable circumstances for taking cash-in lieu:
» Where the local need for parkland can be met by the existing supply of parkland within 800 metres of farthest residential land parcel.
» Where the site would not be practical to develop if the amount of parkland required was dedicated.
» Where the required land dedication would not offer a sufficient size, shape or location for development as a park.
As a long term plan to acquire parkland through the subdivision approval process, investigate development of a Parkland Dedication Bylaw.
» Bill 197 restores the Town’s ability to pass a Parkland Dedication Bylaw to make use of the Alternative Rate permitted for parkland of up to one hectare for 300 units for land or up to one hectare for 500 units for cash-in-lieu. The Town must engage the public in the development of the Bylaw, which can be appealed to the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal (LPAT).
» A parkland dedication bylaw may ensure that a greater quantum of local parkland required to serve future residential areas over 300 residential units is acquired through the subdivision approval process. It is advantageous for proposals that exceed 15 units per hectare.
Maintain a GIS of all parkland by classification type and spatially locate all parkland assets by park. Consider providing public access to this data.
- Acknowledge Smiths Falls as a motorized and nonmotorized regional trail hub in the future update to the Town’s Official Plan.
<em>Priority:</em> Complete the Vision for Waterfront Parks in Collaboration <em>with Parks Canada.</em>
Rationale
The Town of Smiths Falls and Parks Canada own and maintain public waterfront lands for recreational enjoyment, economic development, protection of national heritage, and restoration of natural systems. Balancing these interests and coordinating development projects within and between multiple organizations is challenging but necessary for shorearea focused enhancements at Lower Reach Park, Centennial Park and Murphy Park.
The Town’s Downtown Strategy and Strategic Plan commit strategic attention and resources to downtown transformation; investment in waterfront parks is vital to achieving the ambition contemplated in these strategies, particularly to attract private investment.
The Town’s waterfront parks are among the most frequently used recreational assets and the multi-use trails that connect them with the broader community are regarded as the most important priority for future investment, based on findings from the coded resident survey.
Actions to advance in a Waterfront Parks Plan
Passive parkland use of the Town’s waterfront parks rank among the highest outdoor recreation priorities, particularly for picnics, BBQs and special events and festivals.
A design-oriented master plan that prioritizes and coordinates a range of complex and relatively minor improvement projects that are necessary in these parks will help each entity to forecast and budget for respective projects with increased certainty that the project’s design and implementation goals meet pre-approved requirements.
• Focus on diversifying play opportunities in Waterfront Parks through playground equipment renewals and equipment additions. These efforts should seek to increase natural, adventure and dynamic play equipment and also ensure that the playground inventory can meet the needs of a broader range of age groups.
• Plan for designated spaces for special events and small gatherings. Amenities such as picnic tables and picnic pads with shelters are likely to be highly utilized.
• Add extensions from the multi-use recreational trails network in Lower Reach Park to internal park areas (i.e., major fields, sport courts, play equipment) to achieve accessibility.
• Widen and resurface the multi-use recreational trail with a hard surface to promote greater accessibility and increased multi-direction travel.
• Identify and prioritize shore areas for naturalization and restoration efforts.
• Delineate and design areas for visitor parking.
• Design the waterfront for accessibility, with an active, aging population in mind.
• Design plans to address the gaps in multi-use recreational trail connectivity, particularly between Lower Reach Park and Victoria Park.
• Design and approval of location of park comfort and sanitation amenities including benches and dual-stream waste and recycling containers.
• Ensure that sustainability and environmental mitigation strategies are primary considerations when contemplating future park investment.
6
A FRAMEWORK FOR PRIORITIZING INDOOR AND OUTDOOR FUTURE NEEDS
The Prioritization Framework
Indoor and outdoor recreation facility priorities outlined in this section were identified using a three-step approach, resulting in the development of Infrastructure Action Plans. This approach supports transparent decision making and ensures that prioritization and strategic direction is well informed by sound data and rationale collected throughout the planning process.
Step 1
Service Level Needs Assessment
Step 2
Investment Prioritization Ranking
Step 3
Infrastructure Action Plans
What are the purposes and outcomes of each step?
Step 1: Service Level Needs Assessment - Uses 6 key criteria from the research and engagement to assess whether amenity service levels should be reduced, maintained, or expanded. This step is an initial filter that provides a basis for the more detailed analysis undertaken in Step 2.
Step 2: Investment Prioritization Ranking – Amenities that Step 1 suggests should be maintained or expanded proceed to this step and are ranked. This ranking carries forward the 6 criteria from Step 1 and also adds 7 additional criteria that reflect practical factors that the Town must consider when prioritizing future projects and resource allocation. Step 2 is undertaken based on a recognition that the Town may not be able to maintain or expand all amenity types identified in Step 1 and needs to prioritize investment based on an expanded list of criteria considerations.
Step 3: Action Plans – The Step 2 rankings inform action plans for each type / category of parks, and recreation infrastructure. Similar to the Service Delivery Strategies provided in Section 6, these action plans suggest future actions and next steps for recreation infrastructure. This step applies a practical lens to the Step 1 and 2 analysis and adjusts where necessary based on factors such as available land, potential synergies with previously confirmed projects, potential partnerships, and financial realities of the Town.
Overview of the Criteria Used for the Steps 1 and 2 Analysis
The criteria below were applied to all indoor and outdoor recreation facilities in a two-step process to objectively determine the relative importance of investing in the infrastructure. A comment on the importance of each criteria used is noted for context. A weighting scale (1-3) is applied to the Step 2 criteria to reflect that while all criteria are important, some warrant a high degree of consideration in the prioritization process.
| # | Criteria | Why is this criteria important to consider when determining future priorities? | Applied to Step 1: Service Level Needs Assessment | Applied to Step 2: Investment Prioritization Ranking |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Resident Preferences and Demands | Resident needs and preferences should be a primary consideration when setting future investment priorities. | ✓ | ✓ |
| 2 | Stakeholder and User Group Preferences | Local and regional community organizations are a key delivery agent of programs, events and other activities. As such, it is important to consider their needs and preferences when setting priorities. | ✓ | ✓ |
| 3 | Youth Engagement | The provision of quality parks and recreation services have a significant impact on child and youth development and help connect this important cohort of residents to the community (providing a diverse array of long term benefits). | ✓ | ✓ |
| 4 | Utilization and Capacity Indicators | If utilization of a facility or amenity is nearing capacity or conversely is underutilized, these factors should influence prioritization. | ✓ | ✓ |
| 5 | Trends | Broader regional, provincial, and national trends, while they can be somewhat anecdotal and subjective, are nonetheless important to consider as part of future service level assessment and prioritization. | ✓ | ✓ |
| 6 | Benchmarking | Benchmarking contrasts how Smiths Falls compares to other communities in the area and provides some level of insight into expected amenity service levels. | ✓ | ✓ |
| 7 | Existing Provision | The Town is responsible for an asset base worth hundreds of millions of dollars. The Town cannot realistically assess prioritization from a starting point that ignores historical context and its responsibilities for existing infrastructure. | ✓ | |
| 8 | Regional Supply | Residents living in the County have access to an abundance of parks and recreation infrastructure and often cross municipal boundaries to access these opportunities. This criteria recognizes that the Town needs to consider what exists in other communities (and the risk of duplicating facilities) when setting priorities. | ✓ | |
| 9 | Amenity Adaptability and Flexibility | Amenity types that can accommodate multiple purposes and / or be easily adapted for other uses maximize the use of available resources. | ✓ | |
| 10 | Financial Accessibility | Inclusion and access are key pillars of the Town's strategic service delivery mandate (as per the Service Delivery Outcomes in Section 5). As such, those amenities that are likely to be available at no or low cost should be prioritized over those amenities that are less so. | ✓ | |
| 11 | Project Development Costs | The Town needs to carefully assess how to make optimal use of available and limited capital funds. This criteria factors in construction cost and value. | ✓ | |
| 12 | Operating Costs Impacts | Before proceeding with capital development, the Town also needs to carefully analyze the operational cost impacts of bringing online new or enhanced facilities. | ✓ | |
| 13 | Economic Benefits | Parks and recreation infrastructure can bring visitors to a community and generate non-local spending. | ✓ |
The results from the Step 1 (Service Level Needs Assessment) and Step 2 (Investment Prioritization Ranking) analysis are provided for each amenity type (this is indicated by the number beside each facility type in the Investment Prioritization Ranking box). Please refer to Appendix A for the detailed Step 1 evaluation metric and results and Appendix B for the detailed Step 2 evaluation metric and results.
7
RENEWING OUTDOOR FACILITIES
SOLUTIONS
Inventory of Outdoor Recreation Facilities and Amenities
Smiths Falls provides a broad range of parks and recreation facilities and amenities, each with its own legacy and positive impact on the generations of users that have enjoyed using or spending time at it. These facilities and amenities form part of a bigger local and regional system of publicly accessible parks, school board fields, conservation areas, privately owned and operated recreation facilities, and facilities operated by public institutions, such as schools and health facilities. Only facilities and spaces that are owned or that are operated by the Town of Smiths Falls are included in the inventory overview provided on the following pages.
Source: smithsfalls.ca
Outdoor Facility Inventory
Provision Ratio (residents per unit of amenity type)
| # | Number of Facilities | Provision Ratio (residents per unit of amenity type) | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baseball Diamonds | Rectangular Fields (full size) | Pickleball Courts (Lined) | ||
| # | 9 | # | # | # |
| 9 | 976 | 7 | 1,254 | 3 |
| Tennis Courts | Paved Outdoor Courts | Lawn Bowling Complex | ||
| # | 6 | # | # | # |
| 1,463 | 3 | 2,927 | 1 | 8,780 |
Pickleball Courts (Lined)
| Bocce Court#18,780 | Sand VolleyballCourts#18,780 | Splash Pad#18,780 |
|---|---|---|
| Playground | Dog Off Leash Areas | Outdoor Fitness Base |
|---|---|---|
| 6 1,463 | 2 4,390 | 1 8,780 |
| Skate Park# 8,780 | Pump Track# 0 | Outdoor Rink# 1 | 8,780 |
|---|
Playground Replacement Action Plan
Service Level Needs Assessment
Playgrounds (Expand Provision)
Investment
Prioritization
Ranking
Ranking Playgrounds (Expand Provision)
Playgrounds (Outdoor - 2)
Current Supply
6 playground sites
Recommended Future Actions
Recommended facility specific and location-level actions and rationale for existing and proposed playground sites are provided below and in the following table. This strategy is supported by a comprehensive Smiths Falls Playground Provision Strategy that presents trends in playground design, equipment selection, maintenance and operations, and capital replacement. This document is presented under a separate cover and should be considered alongside the actions provided below.
Facility Specific Actions
• Establish a playground replacement program as an annual capital budget line item to address ongoing asset management needs, including accessibility upgrades (equipment, pathways, seating, etc.).
• Ensure that playgrounds are provided in new residential development areas based on an 800-metre service area. Playground equipment should be installed during the initial phases of Bellamy Farms development.
Location Specific Actions
| Action | Location | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Remove | Civitian Park (Community Park) | The equipment at this location is at the end of its lifecycle and should be removed. It likely receives minimal use based on its current condition. Civitan Park is within 200m of the playground at Lower Reach Park so there is no consequential service level impact associated with removal. |
| These playgrounds should be removed from the inventory and not replaced. | Lower Reach Park (equipment beside Tennis Courts) (Waterfront Park) | The equipment at this location is at the end of its lifecycle and should be removed. Consolidating all play structures in a single area of Lower Reach Park will offer a higher quality experience for children and optimize use of support amenities such as the spray pad and washrooms that are adjacent to the larger existing structures. |
| Replace | Hyland & Corbett Park (Local Park) | The equipment at this location is at the end of lifecycle and should be replaced. A community-inspired park renewal project that considers both Hyland and Corbett Park should be developed by the Town to ensure the location and characteristics of the playground and other amenities at these parks address the needs of the local area. |
| These Playgrounds should be replaced with new. | Victoria Park (wood equipment) (Waterfront Park) | The equipment at this location is at end of lifecycle and should be replaced. Relocating the replacement equipment to the former RV campsite (Parks Canada property) would provide a more defined and larger play area and otherwise make a reasonable use of a space that will be returned to a naturalized state. |
| Enhance & Renew These playgrounds should be renewed and enhanced given the significance of the site. | Lower Reach Park (Waterfront Park) | The two-major pieces of playground equipment at Lower Reach Park are the most significant in the Town's inventory and serve a Town-wide and beyond catchment. This is a destination playground. The Playground Inspection Report for this location identified several requirements that can be addressed as part of a significant renewal and enhancement project. A site master plan prepared by a qualified individual should be prepared to achieve the following:• Delineation of the playground area. Consider space for additional equipment pieces that can be added in future phases.• Recommended surfacing material to be used throughout.• Hard surface paths that provide accessible pedestrian connections between the parking area, playground, splash pad, and washrooms/snack bar building.• Provision of a defined parking area for playground visitors. Accessible parking should be provided.• Locations for shade and seating should be provided. |
| Add These playgrounds should be added to the inventory because of an existing gap in service provision or due to future growth | Memorial Arena Community Centre | A new Community playground should be provided at this location to provide access to residents in surrounding residential areas. The grounds of the Memorial Arena have sufficient space to accommodate multiple pieces of equipment, particularly highly visible spaces adjacent to the Sens Rink. Existing parking, lighting and accessible washroom facilities complement investment in play equipment at this location. |
| Add These playgrounds should be added to the inventory because of an existing gap in service provision or due to future growth | Bellamy Farms (Local Park) | A Local Playground should be provided in newly acquired parkland. |
Outdoor Facilities - Sports Courts and Surfaces Action Plan
Service Level Needs Assessment
Outdoor Paved Court Spaces (Maintain)
Pickleball Courts (Maintain / Expand)
Sand Volleyball Court (Maintain)
Tennis Courts (Maintain)
Bocce Court (Maintain)
Lawn Bowling Green (Maintain)
Investment
Prioritization
Ranking
Outdoor Paved Court Spaces (Outdoor – 7)
Pickleball Courts (Outdoor – 8)
Sand Volleyball Court (Outdoor – 10)
Tennis Courts (Outdoor – 17)
Bocce Court (Outdoor – 17)
Lawn Bowling Green (Outdoor – 18)
Current Supply
2 Paved Sport Courts
6 Lit Tennis Courts (3 with pickleball lines)
1 Sand Volleyball Court
1 Bocce Court
1 Lawn Bowling Complex
Recommended Future Actions
• Resurface the paved sport court at Lower Reach Park. Provide court lighting and connect to parking area by a defined internal multi-recreational trail or park path.
• Continue to monitor pickleball activity trends and regional provision.
• As sport court development or resurfacing opportunities arise, investigate new amenity additions and surfacing types that can maximize the multi-use nature and benefits of these spaces.
Sports Fields and Ball Diamonds Action Plan
Service Level Needs Assessment
Sports Fields (Maintain Provision)
Ball Diamonds (Maintain Provision)
Investment
Prioritization
Ranking
Ranking Sports Fields (Maintain Provision)
Sports Fields (Outdoor - 13)
Ball Diamonds (Outdoor - 16)
Current Supply
9 Ball Diamonds
7 Sport Fields
Recommended Future Actions
• Develop a refreshed sports field allocation policy.
• Enhance data collection and analysis to monitor use, particularly the level of use by non-resident teams.
• Assess removing the ball diamond at Hyland & Corbett Park as part of a broader playground renewal and park revisioning process recommended in the Playground Action Plan section.
• Consider relocating or removing the small diamond at Lower Reach Park (beside the building) to improve access to and provide expansion room for the playground area and minimize risk of errant balls.
• Inspect field lighting equipment and ensure replacement costs are tracked in the Town’s Asset Management program. Adopt SMART field lighting switches to ensure lights are on only for scheduled and permitted periods to reduce utility costs. This can be controlled through a mobile application to minimize staff call-outs in the event of disruption.
Source: smithsfalls.ca
Action Plan For Other Outdoor Amenities
The following chart provides additional direction for several specialized amenity types.
| Amenity Type | Service Level Needs Assessment | Investment Prioritization Ranking* | Recommended Future Actions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spray parks | Maintain Provision | Outdoor 5 | • Sustain the existing spray features at Lower Reach Park |
| Pump tracks / bike skills parks | Maintain Provision | Outdoor – 4 | • Continue to monitor trends and consider community driven requests for pump tracks and skills parks |
| Skate parks | Maintain Provision | Outdoor - 11 | • Continue to sustain the existing skate park but adding additional equipment |
| Outdoor fitness equipment | Maintain Provision | Outdoor 12 | • Consider adding outdoor fitness equipment and features as part of future park development and enhancement projects –particularly at Victoria Park |
| Tennis courts Pickleball courts | Maintain Provision | Outdoor – 15Outdoor - 8 | • Maintain courts lines for tennis and pickleball at the Town’s two locations |
| Sand volleyball courts | Maintain Provision | Outdoor - 10 | • Consider adding courts as part of future park development and enhancement projects |
| Lawn bowling complex/greens | Reduce | Outdoor - 18 | • Consider alternative uses of this site if the Lawn Bowling Club is unable to sustain membership and offer programs |
*refer to Appendix for information on the ranking.
Source: smithsfalls.ca
8
RENEWING AND DIVERSIF YING INDOOR FACILITIES
Construction
Indoor recreation facilities are important to residents and the organizations that use them to provide sport and recreation services to the public. The Town invests in this infrastructure to promote physical activity, healthy lifestyles, skill development, competition, community building, and economic growth. This section offers guidance and action plans to guide decision making over the next 10 years.
Existing Inventory of Indoor Recreation Facilities
The Town of Smiths Falls owns and operates the major recreational facilities listed below.
| Facility Name | Use Type | Risk of Replacement by 2030 – SF Asset Management Plan (Sept 2016) | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| Memorial Community Centre and Youth Arena | Active Participation | Low | 2 arenas (ice in winter; floor in summer); indoor walking track; 2 halls |
| Heritage House Museum | Museum | Low | Victorian home restored to 1865-1875 period; several rooms open to public for viewing; special events; gift shop; craft room; meeting space; Grassed area/grounds |
| Seniors Centre | Activity Centre | Low | Building dedicated to seniors' activity; cards; fitness; shuffleboard etc. |
| Lawn Bowling Club | Active Centre | n/a | Clubhouse with lawn bowling greens |
| Station Theatre | Theatre | Low | Building with auditorium; seating; stage; kitchen; meeting area; lounge area |
| Child Development Centre | Daycare | Low | Daycare with outdoor play structure; grass area for play; storage shed; shelter |
Indoor Multi-Sport Facilities Action Plan
Service Level Needs Assessment
Indoor Multi Sport Facility (Expand)
Investment
Prioritization
Ranking
Indoor Multi-Sport Facility (Indoor - 1)
Current Supply
The Town does not provide an indoor multi-court facility that can accommodate a variety of activity types
Recommended Future Actions:
• Continue to optimize community use of the Board of Education gymnasiums and, where possible, determine solutions and approaches to issues that limit community gymnasium time.
• Undertake an Indoor Multi Sport Facility Feasibility Study with interested surrounding municipalities and the Upper Canada District School Board to assess demand, viability, and model of operation of an indoor multi-sport facility on municipal or Board of Education lands.
• Participate as a stakeholder in regional discussions on potential indoor multi-sport field facilities.
Smiths Falls Memorial Community Centre
SMITHS FALLS
Source: smithsfalls.ca
Arenas Action Plan
Service Level Needs Assessment
Ice arenas (Maintain)
Investment
Prioritization
Ranking
Ice arenas (Indoor - 7)
Current Supply
2 indoor ice sheets (2 connected but independent facilities)
1 outdoor natural rink with lights (Sens Rink)
Current Situation
Long-term demand for arenas and ice surfaces is heavily influenced by demographic shifts and projected population, the current and future supply of available regional ice surfaces, participation trends in volunteer-based ice sport organizations that provide programs for children, youth and adults, and the policies and practices (allocation, pricing, contracts) governing the use of ice surfaces provided by the Town.
Considering time loss due to cleaning and other Covid-19 requirements, prime time use of both arena surfaces was 89% in 2020/2021. This high level of utilization has been achieved through optimized allocation and scheduling practices and use by non-residents, many of whom live within the broader region. The Town and adjoining municipalities have an agreement in place that provides respective non-residents with access to arena ice in Smiths Falls. The Town does not currently collect residency statistics.
The current provision of arena ice is 1:4,390 persons, a relatively high service level for Ontario, even considering the agreement the Town has with adjoining municipalities. Utilization is enhanced by nearby non-residents whose respective municipalities make an annual contribution to the operating costs of Memorial Arena, but not the Youth Arena.
Long-term demand indicators, however, suggest that population-based demand for ice time will slowly decline as the general population ages and current adult players ‘age-out’ of ice-based sporting activities. Given
the relatively few hours of ice dedicated to recreational and introductory-level ice sport programs offered, fewer hours of future ice time should be anticipated for those players that do learn to play ice sports during their youth and play into adulthood compared to historical patterns of activity. Residents also indicated a strong preference through the household survey for the Town to provide non-ice-based recreational programs and facilities, suggesting that the pathways for increasing participation in ice sports will face some local headwinds.
The Town should continue to monitor utilization of the ice surfaces and collect additional statistics from seasonal permit holders to build a more robust trends database for monitoring changes in participation and utilization by ice sport as well as the residency of all uses/players (Town of Smiths Falls resident or non-resident). These efforts will assist staff in continuing to optimize utilization of rinks and inform future discussion with surrounding municipalities about allocation of operating and capital costs related to the provision of arena ice.
The Youth Arena is also nearing a lifecycle period where a renewal of original ice plant equipment is anticipated. Triggers of this nature present an opportunity to either confirm the future business case for continuing to operate the Youth Arena as a second indoor ice surface or to consider alternative uses.
Recommended Future Actions:
• While demand for prime time utilization of ice at the Youth Arena is expected to remain strong, if annual overall utilization falls below 60% of total available hours annually for two consecutive years, an Arena Ice Review should be undertaken to assess future ice requirements.
• Continue to monitor prime time and shoulder season utilization closely and enhance statistics collected from permit holders to track trends in player participation and residency. Provide a utilization report to Council annually.
•
Work with ice arena user groups to determine strategies to increase participation and ice arena utilization within the parameters of their governing sport bodies Long Term Player Development plans. Ice sport user groups are encouraged to offer recreational, learn-to-play programs that introduce children and youth to fundamental skills.
EXIT
Aquatics Action Plan
Current Situation
The Town offers access to outdoor river swimming at Murphy
Park in the summer, including providing climbing inflatables.
Two non-operational wading pools exist at Victoria Park and
Hyland Park respectively.
Survey respondents indicated use of the municipal pool in Perth or the private aquatics facility at the Gallipeau Centre (which has subsequently permanently closed). A variety of stakeholders indicated that an indoor pool would be appropriate for Smiths Falls.
Recommended Future Actions
• Given the significant development and operational cost associated with adding an aquatics facility to the Town’s asset base, and the proximity of other publicly accessible indoor pools in the region, an indoor aquatics facility is not recommended.
•
Remove the non-operational wading pools from their current locations as these assets have reached the end of their lifecycle.
Swimming
Fitness Spaces Action Plan
Service Level Needs Assessment
Fitness facilities (Maintain Provision)
Investment
Prioritization
Ranking
Fitness facilities (Indoor – 6)
Current Supply
The Town does not provide a fitness facility
Recommended Future Actions
• Commercial operators are active in this space and appear to satisfy community demand. The Town should not provide or operate fitness facilities.
100
Action Plan For Other Indoor Amenities
The following chart provides additional direction for several specialized amenity types.
| Amenity Type | Service Level Needs Assessment | Investment Prioritization Ranking* | Recommended Future Actions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Youth spaces | Expand Provision | Indoor - 3 | • Continue the partnership with Big Brothers Big Sisters to provide the Youth Arena Lounge as a temporary space for the youth centre • Recognizing the degree to which youth use and value parks, identify opportunities to integrate interesting and appealing amenities into these spaces |
| Seniors spaces | Maintain Provision | Indoor - 7 | • Continue to support the Seniors Centre • Continue to operate the indoor walking track |
| Indoor Walking Track | Expand Provision | Indoor - 2 | • Implement a method of tracking frequency of use |
*refer to Appendix for information on the ranking.
9
MASTER PLAN IMPLEMENTATION
Activation of the Recreation Master Plan is critical to its success. This requires coordinated efforts and a commitment from Council, staff, stakeholders, and the public, as well as a variety of funding options to implement the Plan. This section provides guidance on the Master Plan’s implementation over the next 10 years.
PARK
Potential Funding Opportunities
Continual investment is required to advance the priorities and action identified in this Master Plan. To assist with implementation, a selection of more common financing opportunities are identified below.
Municipal Reserves
Industry standards suggest that 2.5% of the capital replacement value of assets be earmarked to a replacement reserve annually. These funds ensure good-state of repair and proper maintenance and inspections are completed routinely. Smiths Falls should consider a playground renewal reserve to fund future replacements or upgrades of play structure equipment.
Development Charges
Smiths Falls has recently studied collecting Development charges - fees that are collected through the development process to provide growth related infrastructure, such as new or enhanced facilities or parks. Eligible capital projects may be fully funded through development changes - particularly development of local parks in larger new residential areas.
Cash in Lieu
Cash in lieu of a dedication of parkland is permitted under the Planning Act and currently collected by Smiths Falls. These funds can be used to acquire additional parkland or for development of parkland. Cash in Lieu of parkland collected on smaller land developments should be considered for allocation to the highest eligible Master Plan priorities.
User Fees
Users fees vary depending on cost recovery requirements and other municipal policies and considerations related to setting fees. Smiths Falls should review the user fee structure for each facility type and service regularly and prior to making major reinvestments. User fees should be applied equitably.
Partnerships
Partnerships are an increasingly common strategy for developing and operating major facilities and services; partners may be any combination of: municipalities, school board, not-for-profit association, or the private sector. Smiths Falls agreement with adjacent municipalities for the operation of the Memorial Arena is a example.
Monitoring and Updating the Master Plan
The Town should regularly review and assess, and periodically revise the actions of the Master Plan to ensure that they remain reflective of local conditions and responsive to the changing needs of the community. This will require monitoring of activity patterns and facility utilization, regular dialogue with community organizations, and updating the plan every five to ten years. Through these mechanisms – or as a result of other internal or external factors – adjustment of the priorities identified in this Plan may be required.
The Town should develop a system for the regular monitoring, ongoing implementation and reporting on the progress of the Master Plan, such as the collection of participation data and annual reports to Council and/or the community. The following steps may be used to conduct an annual review of the Master Plan:
• Review of the past year (recommendations implemented, capital projects undertaken, changes in facility utilization levels, issues arising from the public and community groups, etc.);
• Identification of service level interests and issues impacting the coming year (anticipated financial and operational constraints, emerging opportunities, etc.);
• Communication to staff and Council regarding the status of projects, criteria used to prioritize projects used for the Master Plan and projects to be implemented in the coming year; and
• Consideration of triggers noted in the Master Plan that specify a predetermined action or response.
PARKWAY
Advancing Highest Priority Projects that Require Capital Funding
The highest facility priority for capital funding is the replacement and renewal of playground equipment at most playground sites. Sustained, multi-year funding is required to complete the program and to ensure that resources are available for annual maintenance and repairs, and eventual replacement again. The table below provides a plan to schedule a work and funding program over the next 5 years. Capital funding of more than $1 million is required over 5 years.
| Action | Scope | Estimated Funding Required Funding (2022 dollars) | Timing | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Replace Playground at Victoria Park | See Playground Replacement Strategy for guidance | $125,000 (site works, installation, play equipment) | 2022 | Removal of the existing wading pool should be completed at this location in conjunction with construction at this site. |
| Replace Playground at Hyland Park | See Playground Replacement Strategy for guidance | $125,000 (site works, installation, play equipment) | 2022 | |
| Neighbourhood consultation, site design and equipment selection for all playground sites | Detailed design packages with technical specifications are prepared for each site | $40-50,000 | 2023 | This planning effort can be phased over multiple years based on available funding. |
| Enhance and Renew Playground at Lower Reach Park | See Playground Replacement Strategy for guidance | $250,000-$300,000 (site works, installation, play equipment) | 2025 | This location is identified as a community-wide Accessible Playground |
| Add a Playground at the Memorial Arena Community Centre | See Playground Replacement Strategy for guidance | $250,000 (site works, installation, play equipment) | 2026-27 | This is a new site. A location will be required. |
APPENDICES
Appendix A: Service Level Needs Assessment (Step 1)
Metric
| # | Service Needs Criteria | Indicators |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Resident Preferences | Expand: Identified as a top 5 Indoor or Outdoor priority by Household Questionnaire respondents (coded or non-coded samples). |
| 1 | Resident Preferences | Maintain: Not identified as a top 5 Indoor or Outdoor priority by Household Questionnaire respondents (coded or non-coded samples). |
| 1 | Resident Preferences | Reduce: N/A |
| 2 | Stakeholder and User Group Preferences | Expand: Engagement with community organizations identified the need to expand the current provision (the amenity type was commonly referenced as requiring increased or improved provision during the stakeholder discussions) |
| 2 | Stakeholder and User Group Preferences | Maintain: Engagement with community organizations reflect some perceived need for expanded provision (the amenity type was referenced by multiple groups during the stakeholder discussions). |
| 2 | Stakeholder and User Group Preferences | Reduce: The amenity type was commonly referenced in the stakeholder engagement as being oversupplied with a need to reduce provision levels. |
| 3 | Youth Engagement | Expand: Identified as a top 5 Indoor or Outdoor priority by Youth Survey respondents (coded or non-coded samples). |
| 3 | Youth Engagement | Maintain: Not identified as a top 5 Indoor or Outdoor priority by Youth Survey respondents. |
| 3 | Youth Engagement | Reduce: N/A |
| 4 | Utilization and CapaTown Indicators | Expand: Utilization analysis suggests that the amenity type is nearing or over capacity. Maintain: Utilization analysis suggests that the amenity type is moderately used, but not at or nearing capacity. *Amenity types for which sufficient data isn't available to support "Expand" or "Reduce" are assessed as "Maintain". Reduce: Utilization analysis suggests that the amenity type is underutilized. |
| 5 | Trends | Expand: Regional, provincial and national trends suggest that there will be increasing demand in the future for the amenity type or the types of activities that take place at the amenity type. Maintain: Regional, provincial and national trends suggest that there will be similar demands in the future for the amenity type or the types of activities that take place at the amenity type. Reduce: Regional, provincial and national trends suggest that there will be decreasing demands in the future for the amenity type or the types of activities that take place at the amenity type. |
| 6 | Benchmarking | Expand: The provision of the amenity type is "Lesser" in Smiths Falls relative to comparator municipalities. Maintain: The provision of the amenity type is "Similar" or marginally "Better" in Smiths Falls relative to comparator municipalities. Reduce: The provision of the amenity type is significantly "Better" in Smiths Falls relative to the comparator municipalities. *Amenities for which a benchmarking rating (lesser, similar, or better) was not able to be assigned due to a lack of information are assessed as "Maintain" |
OVERALL ASSESSMENT EVALUATION
“Enhance “ in 3 or more of the 5 categories
“Reduce” in 3 or more of the 5 categories Does
not meet the above criteria
Indoor Amenity Assessment
| Amenity Type | Resident Preferences and Demands | Stakeholder and User Group Preferences | Youth Engagement | Utilization and Capacity Indicators | Participation Trends | Benchmarking | Overall Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Indoor walking / running tracks | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Indoor Aquatics | Expand | Expand | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Arts and crafts creative spaces | Expand | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Indoor multi-sport facilities (e.g. field house with large multi-use surface(s) that can accommodate a variety of activity types) | Expand | Expand | Expand | Maintain | Expand | Maintain | Expand |
| Fitness facilities | Maintain | Maintain | Expand | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Indoor children’s play spaces | Expand | Expand | Expand | Maintain | Expand | Expand | Maintain |
| Multi-purpose program rooms | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Seniors spaces | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Youth spaces | Expand | Expand | Expand | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Expand |
| Gymnasiums / flexi-halls | Maintain | Expand | Maintain | Expand | Expand | Maintain | Expand |
| Ice arenas | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Reduce | Reduce | Maintain | Maintain |
Outdoor Assessment
| Amenity Type | Resident Preferences and Demands | Stakeholder and User Group Preferences | Youth Engagement | Utilization and Capacity Indicators | Participation Trends | Benchmarking | Overall Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Multi-Use Recreation Trails (hard and natural surface) | Expand | Expand | Expand | Expand | Expand | Expand | Expand |
| BBQ and picnic areas / park shelters | Expand | Expand | Expand | n/a | Expand | Maintain | Expand |
| Spray parks | Expand | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Playgrounds | Expand | Expand | Expand | Expand | Expand | Maintain | Expand |
| Outdoor festival and community performance spaces (e.g. amphitheater and urban event plazas) | Expand | Expand | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Dog parks | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Expand | Maintain | Maintain |
| Community Gardens | Expand | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Expand | Expand | Expand |
| Outdoor fitness base | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Pickleball courts | Maintain | Expand | Maintain | Maintain | Expand | Maintain | Maintain |
| Pump tracks / bike skills parks | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Expand | Expand | Maintain |
| Outdoor paved court spaces (for basketball, ball hockey, etc.) | Maintain | Expand | Maintain | Expand | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Sports fields (rectangular sports fields for soccer, football, rugby, etc.) | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain / Reduce | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Ball diamonds | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Reduce | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Skate parks | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Expand | Maintain | Maintain |
| Tennis courts | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Sand volleyball courts | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Bocce Court | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
| Lawnbowling Green | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Reduce | Reduce | Maintain | Maintain |
| Outdoor Rink (Sens Rink) | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain | Maintain |
Appendix B: Investment Prioritization Ranking (Step 2)
| # | Prioritization Criteria | 3 PTS | 2 PTS | 1 PT | 0 PTS | Weighting |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Resident Preferences | Identified as a top 5 Indoor or Outdoor priority by Household Questionnaire respondents (coded or non-coded samples). | Identified as a 6 - 10 Indoor or Outdoor priority by Household Questionnaire respondents (coded or non-coded samples). | Not a top 10 Indoor or Outdoor priority but selected by 10% or more of Household Questionnaire respondents (coded or non-coded samples). | Not a top 10 Indoor or Outdoor priority or selected by 10% or more of Household Questionnaire respondents (coded or non-coded samples). | 3 |
| 2 | Stakeholder and User Group Preferences | Commonly identified as a priority during the user group engagement.*the amenity type was commonly identified as a potential priority during the stakeholder discussions. | Some priority identification during the stakeholder and user group engagement.*potential needs was referenced by multiple groups during the stakeholder discussions. | N/A | Not identified as a priority. | 2 |
| 3 | Youth Engagement | Identified as a top 5 Indoor or Outdoor priority by Youth Survey respondents (coded or non-coded samples). | Identified as a 6 - 9 Indoor or Outdoor priority by Youth Survey respondents. | N/A | Not identified as a top 10 priority by Youth Survey respondents. | 2 |
| 4 | Utilization and Capacity Indicators | Utilization analysis suggests that the amenity type is nearing or over capacity. | Utilization analysis suggests that the amenity type is moderately used, but not at or nearing capacity. *Amenity types for which sufficient data isn't available or are spontaneous use with no current data are assessed a "2" score | N/A | Utilization analysis suggests that the amenity type is underutilized. | 2 |
| 5 | Trends | Regional, provincial and national trends suggest that there will be increasing demand in the future for the amenity type or the types of activities that take place at the amenity type. | Regional, provincial and national trends suggest that there will be similar demands in the future for the amenity type or the types of activities that take place at the amenity type. | N/A | Regional, provincial and national trends suggest that there will be decreasing demands in the future for the amenity type or the types of activities that take place at the amenity type. | 1 |
| 6 | Benchmarking | The provision of the amenity type is "Lesser" in Smiths Falls relative to comparator municipalities. | The provision of the amenity type is "Similar" in Smiths Falls relative to comparator municipalities. *Amenities for which a benchmarking rating (lesser, similar, or better) was not able to be assigned due to a lack of information are assessed a "2" score. | The provision of the amenity type is marginally "Better" in Smiths Falls relative to comparator municipalities. | The provision of the amenity type is significantly "Better" in Smiths Falls relative to comparator municipalities. | 1 |
| 7 | Existing Provision Responsibility | The Town is heavily invested in the amenity type (owns multiple of the amenity type and/ or the replacement value of the asset(s) exceeds $500M *Outdoor amenities for which the Town has a legislated and/or internal policy responsibility for the land in which these activities take place on are also assigned a "3" score. | The Town is moderately invested in the amenity type (the Town may own one or more of the amenity type; replacement value of this infrastructure is between $250-500K). | The Town is minimally invested in the amenity type (the Town may own one or more of the amenity type; replacement value of owned infrastructure is less than $250,000). *Amenities not owned but contributed to through grants or operational partnerships are assessed a "1" score where deemed applicable. | The Town has no investment in the amenity type. | 2 |
| 8 | Regional Supply | The amenity type is not available in Smiths Falls or elsewhere in the immediate region (not available in municipalities adjacent to Smiths Falls). | The amenity type is not available in Smiths Falls and is moderately supplied in the immediate region (municipalities adjacent to Smiths Falls provide at least one of the amenity type). | The amenity type is not available in Smiths Falls but is well supplied in the region (there are multiples of the amenity type in municipalities adjacent to Smiths Falls). | The amenity is available in Smiths Falls. | 1 |
| 9 | Amenity Flexibility and Adaptability | The amenity type is multi-purpose, adaptable to a variety of uses, and serves all age groups. | The amenity type has a defined purpose but accommodates all age groups and ability levels. | The amenity type has a defined purpose and accommodates some age groups and ability levels. | The amenity type is single purpose with limited multi-purpose use, adaptability and serves a defined group of participants. | 1 |
| 10 | Financial Accessibility | The amenity type through its combination of programs/rentals/user fees is likely to be accessible to all residents. | The amenity type through its combination of programs/rentals/user fees is likely to be accessible to most residents. | The amenity type through its combination of programs/rentals/user fees is likely to be accessible to some residents. | The amenity type through its combination of programs/rentals/user fees is likely to be accessible to only a small sub-segment of residents. | 2 |
| 11 | Project Development Cost | Low | Low-Moderate | Moderate | High | 2 |
| 12 | Operating Cost Impacts | Low (the amenity type is likely to operate at a break-even or better position). | Low-Moderate (the amenity type is likely to require a small annual subsidy). | Moderate (the amenity type is likely to require a moderate level of annual subsidy). | High (the amenity type is likely to require a significant annual subsidy). | 2 |
| 13 | Economic Benefits | Amenity type has the potential to draw significant reoccurring non-local spending into the Town. | Amenity type has the potential to draw moderate reoccurring non-local spending into the Town. | Has the potential to draw a small amount of reoccurring non-local spending into the Town. | Does not have the potential to draw any regular non-local spending into the Town. | 1 |
Indoor Amenity Scoring
| Amenity Type | Resident Preferences | Stakeholder and User Group Preferences | Youth Engagement | Utilization and Capacity Indicators | Trends | Benchmarking | Existing Provision Responsibility | Regional Supply | Amenity Flexibility and Adaptability | Financial Accessibility | Project Development Cost | Operating Cost Impacts | Economic Benefits | Score (Weighted) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Indoor walking / running tracks | 2 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 43 |
| Arts and crafts creative spaces | 3 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 37 |
| Indoor multi-sport facilities (e.g. field house with large multi-use surface(s) that can accommodate a variety of activity types) | 3 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 2 | 46 |
| Fitness facilities | 2 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 1 | 35 |
| Indoor children's play spaces | 3 | 3 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 40 |
| Multi-purpose program rooms | 0 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 32 |
| Seniors spaces | 3 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 33 |
| Youth spaces | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 42 |
| Gymnasiums / flexi-halls | 0 | 3 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 24 |
| Ice arenas | 0 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 12 |
Outdoor Amenity Scoring
| Amenity Type | Resident Preferences | Stakeholder and User Group Preferences | Youth Engagement | Utilization and Capacity Indicators | Trends | Benchmarking | Existing Provision Responsibility | Regional Supply | Amenity Flexibility and Adaptability | Financial Accessibility | Project Development Cost | Operating Cost Impacts | Economic Benefits | Score (Weighted) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Multi-Use Recreation Trails (hard and natural surface) | 3 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 58 |
| BBQ and picnic areas / park shelters | 3 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 41 |
| Spray parks | 1 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 39 |
| Playgrounds | 3 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 58 |
| Outdoor festival and community performance spaces (e.g. amphitheater and urban event plazas) | 3 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 44 |
| Dog parks | 2 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 0 | 39 |
| Community Gardens | 2 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 0 | 35 |
| Outdoor fitness base | 1 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 32 |
| Pickleball courts | 0 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 37 |
| Pump tracks / bike skills parks | 0 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 31 |
| Outdoor paved court spaces (for basketball, ball hockey, etc - Sens Rink.) | 0 | 3 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 38 |
| Sports fields (rectangular sports fields for soccer, football, rugby, etc.) | 0 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 32 |
| Ball diamonds | 0 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 29 |
| Skate parks | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 1 | 33 |
| Tennis courts | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 31 |
| Sand volleyball courts | 0 | 0 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 1 | 35 |
| Bocce Court | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 1 | 26 |
| Lawnbowling Green | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 1 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 1 | 23 |
Priority Ranking – Indoor Amenities
| Rank | Amenity Type | Score (Weighted) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Indoor multi-sport facilities (e.g. field house with large multi-use surface(s) that can accommodate a variety of activity types) | 46 |
| 2 | Indoor walking / running tracks | 43 |
| 3 | Youth spaces | 42 |
| T4 | Indoor children's play spaces | 40 |
| 5 | Arts and crafts creative spaces | 37 |
| 6 | Fitness facilities | 35 |
| 7 | Seniors spaces | 33 |
| T4 | Multi-purpose program rooms | 32 |
| T4 | Gymnasiums / flexi-halls | 24 |
| 8 | Ice arenas | 12 |
Priority Ranking – Outdoor Amenities
| Rank | Amenity Type | Score (Weighted) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Multi-Use Recreation Trails (hard and natural surface) | 58 |
| 2 | Playgrounds | 58 |
| 3 | Outdoor festival and community performance spaces (e.g. amphitheater and urban event plazas) | 44 |
| 4 | BBQ and picnic areas / park shelters | 41 |
| 5 | Spray parks | 39 |
| 6 | Dog parks | 39 |
| 7 | Outdoor paved court spaces (for basketball, ball hockey, etc - Sens Rink.) | 38 |
| 8 | Pickleball courts | 37 |
| 9 | Community Gardens | 35 |
| 10 | Sand volleyball courts | 35 |
| 11 | Skate parks | 33 |
| 12 | Outdoor fitness base | 32 |
| 13 | Sports fields (rectangular sports fields for soccer, football, rugby, etc.) | 32 |
| 14 | Pump tracks / bike skills parks | 31 |
| 15 | Tennis courts | 31 |
| 16 | Ball diamonds | 29 |
| 17 | Bocce Court | 26 |
| 18 | Lawnbowling Green | 23 |
M
SMITHS FALLS RISE AT THE FALLS

